There are actually many overdates that are very common, mostly on Matron Head large cents. One is 1824/2, which is a very common variety, and can...
Toning can severely impact the grade to the naked eye, as there are some coins I've seen where the toning is such that it looks more like...
Definitely a high grade coin with natural luster, but not a proof. Probably a MS-62 or better. If you are flexible enough, you could easily sell it!
Separate names with a comma.