The coin isn't overgraded, and your attempt to call this coin an MS64 is nothing more than an indictment of your own grading skills.
Please guess the assigned grade of this PCGS Franklin Half Dollar and vote in the attached poll. Thank you! [img] As always, comments welcome!
AU55
Bump
Btw, here is the TruView. [img]
[img] I think this coin illustrates that some collectors view surface marks as grade limiters, and are unwilling to market grade such coins even...
NT/MA but ugly
Would you agree that the eye appeal and luster are commensurate with an MS67 coin?
Before I put this coin up on the Bay, I wanted to make sure it isn't some rare variety. The coin looks to have XF details but has been cleaned...
Too dark, no star, per NGC guidelines.
It's hard to judge the grade of the coin from those photos, but even though it is a problem coin, it is still worth VF money at the very least, so...
WOW, Premium Gem surfaces, Full Steps, all on an error coin. That is freaking amazing. It takes a lot to impress me with respect to a war...
+1
Juiced photos and the obverse toning is sketchy but I still think it is MA.
Not even I would be crazy enough to pick the 35-D
certainly a star
MS63
As several people have mentioned, both of those coins are proof coins. The detail of the steps and Monticello is a dead giveaway. The Full Step...
NT/MA on the Morgan but pretty close to environmental damage.
Separate names with a comma.
