+1. This is what I'm trying to say. I don’t think anyone should be 100% dogmatic when evaluating a coin from pictures unless you know the...
I don't think it should be called harshly cleaned. Possibly wiped. It's circulated. Circulated coins pick up rub. They get slid across surfaces....
I had voted, 61 dmpl.
Nice AU55
What I thought I initially saw.
Yes the cheek and obverse fields are too shiny. Definitely cleaned. My initial thought was to question authenticity a bit, but can't really put my...
66
64ish, not sure what might be going on around the eagle's head tho.
MS62. If I'm close I just got lucky. I do think the relatively low mintages of these add to their appeal. On my bucket list.
Not sure why anyone would disagree with this. Detail coins certainly do have a "correct" or "fair" price, and a price at which they are a bargain....
Only the San Fran mint produced these in silver, I believe for both proof and mint sets. But the lack of an S mintmark pretty much guarantees this...
I agree with the guys who say it kind of has an AU look. But I'm guessing it's a slider that was forgiven, and even boosted for color, my best...
The faces/expressions of Williams and the Indian...well, I think this issue could have been better executed. JMO. Not knocking your coin, just a...
Yes, a dealer I make it to once in a while has basically nothing in older classic coinage. He says collectors just keep him cleaned out, and not...
I've been slow in replying, having a hard time making up my mind, reverse 66, obverse 64, gonna vote 65.
I don't know of any specifications, seems like the trend has been that if people are paying their grading fees, they will slab it and stick some...
Thought I'd tag on and post mine, though it's not in great shape. It's also a shipwreck coin, from the Dutch East-Indiaman Hollandia, sunk in...
Interesting coin to gtg on. Really it's the reverse that kept me from guessing 67. But it could very possibly have made it IMO.
That one glows. Obverse looks 66+ (maybe better), I'm going with that.
63
Separate names with a comma.
