Where and in what book does it say eye appeal is part of the grading process? And who decides what eye appeal is? Coins can be accurately graded...
Eye appeal has nothing to do with cac sticker. The only two I would have expected to fail is the IHC and the 42 walker - based off the pictures....
I would tend to agree with you. I notice this more with the newer PCGS and NGC holders(actually any TPG) than in the old slabs. Having said that...
Nice batch of coins.
If it was me I would return the coin if possible. I now look specifically for large cents without that kind of dirt or look around the devices....
Depends - ANAC's will label some that NGC and PCGS do not. Not all are the same. I also like the post by Chris. If I was getting something...
Looks like a button to me. My grandma used to talk about how hard it was to get some of them. She used to have a big old case with older fancy...
It can be fun submitting coins - sometimes even those not worth it. I understand the excitement. Nice batch of coins.
Looks more like oil or corrosion to me - just my opinion of course. Actually reminds me of some gas station parking lot finds.
No flaming - just not my cup of tea. So collect them if you like - and enjoy them.
I agree with Markus.
Doubt it - but how about some clear pictures of the coin and it's edges.
Congrats. I snagged one from work not too long ago. Not sure of the date though.
There is a distinct difference between collector coins and bullion level coins. For example some common date gold coins reflect the price of gold,...
Would I have bought it based off those pictures - no. Then from your pictures you can see it was harshly cleaned - as mentioned in the listing...
Not all nice coins have green beans and not all green beans are nice coins.:) What you have there is a nice coin no matter what.
I agree with Kanga and cascade. I know there was someone that was selling a lot of dmpl and pl raw coins on ebay. Once you had one in hand the...
Well I did not read all 4 pages of responses - but I treat CAC about the same way as I do a tpg. Do I think the coin is graded correctly, do I...
Now I see it. :) I looked at that thing 3 times, glad you pointed it out. :)
Separate names with a comma.
