They do look like they belong together. Same dealer, both NGC and I'm so far upside down on both a 20 ft ladder would not help. ;)
Is it possible that the owner of the coin had a reserve set and bought the coin back?
[ATTACH] [ATTACH]
None above 67.
64
They picked a strange spot to add back the initials. Most initials are in a flat field. Worn or filled dies will hide them.
[ATTACH] [ATTACH] [ATTACH] [ATTACH]
[ATTACH]
[ATTACH] [ATTACH] [ATTACH]
You don't see many half dollars with such a bold clash. They were common with the bust coins but not with the Kennedy half.
[edited]
Nice clash. I would put it in some type of holder to keep it safe. Having it graded would cost too much.
Looks real to me.
66
Nice bold example of MD.
Separate names with a comma.