GD, If you can't consider the possibility that what you are seeing in a crappy photo is toning rather than wear, when nobody else sees wear on...
No problem leadfoot, but I promise you that this coin is a monster. It is by far the most impressive common date MS64* that I own and I own well...
You know I read your initial comment at least a dozen times. I still don't know what it means. I am glad it was meant as a joke and gladly...
This from the guy who thinks PCGS is market grading AU 1883-O Morgans to MS. Who knows, you could be right, they may have actually thought we...
More than $1,200 [IMG]
Game, Set, Match, Lehigh96 wins!
Gopher, I am going to try to ignore most of the responses to you OP since they don't really address the issue that you raised. However, you need...
This is a very good point. GD is analyzing a blown up photograph of the coin whereas multiple graders had the opportunity to view the actual coin...
OK, I am putting you down for #5 & #8. Alright guys, we have 4 guesses. 6 more and I will reveal the answers. I emplore you, if you have no...
Actually, I think the obverse of this coin is hideous. The luster is flat and the surfaces are sub par for an MS64. However, I really can't...
I seem to remember a thread last month right after I first joined cointalk that tried to define a monster toned coin. Your comments are the...
Yeah, There is nothing quite like a rainbow toned 1883-O Morgan Dollar. (photo courtesy of Anaconda Rare Coins) [IMG] :cool:
They are called glasses. Just kidding. Seriously though, you don't need to see the surface preservation or strike to evaluate the eye appeal of...
OK, I am putting you down for #2 and #5.
Final Round-----------------Morgan Dollars The photo below displays 8 Morgan Dollars. Only two of the eight coins received the coveted star...
I guess that makes it all tied up. NGC got the Jefferson's wrong (IMO) and got the Roosevelts right. [IMG] :headbang:
No way man, not me. I bought this one already slabbed. [IMG] :cool:
I would prefer something like this! [IMG]
It is my opinion that questions such as these can best be answered with photos rather than words. I will post photos of two NGC MS64 Morgan...
OK, this might be the nicest 1934-S Slider Peace Dollar in existence. Just look at the luster dripping off the reverse. You gotta check out this...
Separate names with a comma.
