Based on your newest photos, I think it has a good shot at MS65, especially from NGC.
I thought the "sniffer" was the terminology used to describe the new laser system that PCGS uses in the Secure Plus service. Here is the PCGS...
Mine, The other aspects of grading are an evolution of the grading process and aspects of market grading. When a TPG grades an Morgan Dollar...
Would you like to know what year the coin was graded?
Does that mean that you would grade it MS65 if the neck did not have what you consider grade limiting marks? BTW, would you like to know what...
You "price is righted" me on the wrong side of the number. LOL I will post a coin when I get home tonight, be patient guys.
You are confusing what Farazzi was saying. He was talking solely about the practice of market grading coins with wear to mint state grades. This...
So now the defense of your theory is that it can't be proven so why try? In order to be taken seriously, you need to provide some evidence that...
It is an opinion that is fueled by the exact type of propaganda that you are spewing right now. Never once on any forum, magazine, or book have I...
That's funny, Doug can always spot luster breaks from photos. Maybe you could employ him to fufill my very simple request.
Here is a 1939-D Rev of 38 NGC MS67 for comparison purposes. [img] It is just too hard to see the surfaces of your coin from those photos....
Wow, your arrogance knows no boundaries does it? You still after all this time present your opinion as an incontrovertible fact. You have not...
I will go along with that, but I would like to see photos with better lighting and not at an angle before I commit to a grade assessment.
Doug, Do you think I argue with you just for the sake of arguing with you? When you make a post that is incorrect, I feel compelled to point...
I have explained my opinion regarding gradeflation before and we have had this discussion before. I freely admit that gradeflation exists but I...
In my opinion, Doug is 100% correct. The toning on these coins would drive little to no premium.
You have me a little confused. You grade the coin AU58 but make no mention of any wear on the coin. Toning does not equate to wear and the lines...
IMO, Mike's assessment of the grade is spot on! That said, it does not look out of place in an MS65 holder, but no way does this coin ever...
Please guess the grade of this 1922-D Peace Dollar graded by NGC in the attached poll. [img] Comments about the coin and your reason behind...
How about showing me an example of a coin that bears a mint state grade but has obvious wear from circulation. Are you claiming to not have...
Separate names with a comma.
