I agree MS66
Varietyplus listings as well.
NGC 1st Generation Black Slabs drive a hefty premium and the coin is essentially irrelevant.
When you say a few, how many exactly do you have? The minimum submission is 5 coins, so if you have less than that you should probably not join...
So you are indicting them for making a mistake in a 300 page book? The bigger contradiction is your acceptance of "friction from strike" and your...
Both coins have luster grazes on the cheek. You don't penalize a luster graze for intensity because the frost is better on the second coin, it...
The face and date are primary, fields are secondary. Diagram below is from PCGS OFFICIAL GUIDE TO COIN GRADING AND COUNTERFEIT DETECTION. [IMG]
Those photos tell me to run away. AU at best, problem coin at worst.
All three look cleaned to me and your white balance is off in your photos.
If this is true, it should be easy for you to provide us with links to the threads and photos of the coins showing how they graded. In other...
The main focal area of the Morgan Dollar Obverse is the face & date, not the fields.
You have it backwards. The luster grazes seem worse because the frost on the second is so much better. What really separates the 2 coins is how...
When did I ever claim that only Saints were candidates for roll/bag friction? Answer, NEVER! In fact, I wrote a thread about a year ago where I...
One, I don't think there are that many overgraded coins on the market, unless you are looking at ANACS slabs. Second, grading is subjective. How...
What are you talking about? I never bragged about the coin in the OP, I merely stated that the photos were probably exaggerating the flaws based...
You didn't answer my question, you made 4 consecutive ridiculous posts. What proof do you have that the TPGs reward big submitters?
I never collected PL or DMPL Morgan Dollars but I rarely passed on a chance to get a nice Morgan that was prooflike on the obverse only since they...
Where do you see a scratch that would result in a details grade? Furthermore, are you insinuating that ANACS is more conservative in their...
Hey, you can be the leader, the blind leading the blind.
Fine, show them, and let us be the judge.
Separate names with a comma.
