I wouldn’t buy it
That’s very cool
MS64+ MS66
I have other coins going to NGC and they don’t charge you the full fee for designation review. To me, it’s worth $10 to get it reholdered and...
I believe that MS67 5FS is the correct grade. There is some weakness on the 3rd & 4th steps under both the 2nd & 3rd pillar but under a loupe,...
Wait till you see the slab photo, my closeups really don’t do it justice.
Anyone else, I’m going to reveal in a few hours.
+1 Doesn’t look like a luster issue, they were really tough on this coin. I would expect MS63* or MS64* from NGC. Plus I think toned coins look...
This is a very good point and in my experience, not well known. PCGS will allow shallow marks that cross the steps but (in their opinion) don’t...
$47 [IMG]
Please guess the assigned grade of this NGC 1943-S Jefferson Nickel by voting in the attached poll. [img] [img] Thank you, as always, comments...
Looks AU58 to me, a real nice find for an album collection.
Yes, muted luster. And we are judging by a photograph. In hand, there very well might be enough marks to condemn it to a 62. My first...
+1 When I see coins with color like this that don't get any color bump by PCGS, my normal assumption is that the luster is inhibited by the color...
Must be an Ed Wood student.
I would lean towards MA but this is a coin that I would like to see in hand before making a final decision. I don't trust that photo.
Looks GEM to me, MS65 BN, very nice.
Maybe, but your point about time of sale was just validated. I bet I couldn’t sell that coin for even $50 today, much less $70. Now that I know...
Fair enough, but I still don’t consider 3X “strong money”. The real problem with the coin is that it is plainly overgraded and the toning isn’t...
So what, I just scrolled through the Heritage archives and saw plenty that sold for $50 or more. Furthermore, I didn’t see any in the $10-$15...
Separate names with a comma.
