I wouldn’t leave a negative but you can count me in the group that hates the E-Bay feedback system
1). A sold for more 2). $225 3). $200 The toning on A is far superior but the obverse is atrocious and I would never want to own that coin. The...
I’ve tried to explain this several times. I was unaware that they started using NGC photos. Personally I wish they would contract with someone...
Strike is rarely even a consideration for me. As long as the strike is average and there isn’t massive detail loss, I will always choose coins...
I talked myself out of a slider grade into an MS64 and you did the opposite. I think one of us is gonna have egg on our face because IMO, AU58...
That’s nice, obverse looks better than MS65 and the 49-S is very tough in full steps. I would crack that and send to either PCGS or NGC. FWIW,...
I thought that was the reason you posted the photos on their side.
Nah, I’m a toner guy, I covet eye appeal above strike always. I think I have only four 6FS coins in my registry set: 1940, 1940-S, 1942-D, & 1942-P.
So much for starting us off easy Jason. This coin is extremely hard to grade from photos. My initial impression from the top of the eagles wings...
The problem is that very few Jefferson Nickels have 6 full steps.
FYI, only uncirculated examples are eligible for full steps.
Yes, we are gonna need the better photos.
Personally, I abhor the E-Bay feedback system and rarely engage in it at all. As a seller you can’t leave negative feedback which is bull, and I...
I don’t see anything holding this coin back. The surfaces are clean, luster looks strong, and eye appeal is excellent. I see slight bridging on...
Cause luster is important. I view “thick skinned” like “wholly original” and it’s akin to complimenting a person for their personality.
Without the poll, the lurkers have no outlet for their input. The people who respond in comments are usually forum regulars who are not shy about...
To be clear, I don’t mind the coin having the mark in the prime focal area as long as the luster and eye appeal are such that market grading the...
Or is it an accurate photo of a luckluster coin?
Agreed, but people who have purchased coins from Heritage have a huge advantage, even though this particular example was a tough one.
My problem with Heritage photos is that they wash out the luster even on coins that have great luster, making it nearly impossible to tell when a...
Separate names with a comma.
