So you grade this coin an MS63+, but the 1885-S from the previous thread was an MS63?????? Thank you so much, I love a good laugh in the morning.
I’m obviously not on ignore if you are responding to my posts, making you a LIAR! Are you a moderator? If not, it isn’t your job to intervene to...
Ok, let’s see it! Btw, congrats!
Bull, this is a pure troll post. You supposedly had me on ignore, but for some reason took me off ignore and the responded by selectively editing...
Oh boy, after that photo, I’m at MS65/66. I will stick with MS65 since I already changed my grade once.
Ok, I’m at MS65 even though I voted MS64.
I don't know if I'm interpreting these photos correctly, but the obverse seems to have grainy surfaces and much less lustrous than the reverse....
My initial impression of the obverse was MS62, but the reverse is significantly better so I’m bumping it up to a low end MS63 MS63 C
You are describing a scenario dealing with dreck residing in a overgraded holder. In these situations, it will be very difficult to get full...
MS66 Honestly, the surfaces look immaculate and the luster and eye appeal are both off the charts from that photo. The only thing that prevented...
I was on the fence between MS64/65 regarding surfaces but thought that the overall eye appeal would push it up to MS65. The untoned area on the...
This is the entire reason for TPG grading. If TPGs didn’t exist, this unscrupulous dealer could over grade his coins, and he would get his asking...
The first coin is obviously VF35 compared to the 2nd coin which is VF25. Stop changing the subject. Uncirculated coins are graded completely...
No dude, you don’t get to change the rules unless you are starting your own TPG. Eye appeal is an element of market grading, period. Strike...
So what, they don’t grade those coins the same way US Coins are graded. I could easily make the argument that those knife coins are of varying...
Price is secondary, the fact is that those coins I showed are better than your run of the mill 1880-S MS65 Morgan Dollar, and they deserve a...
MS65*
It isn’t a grade bump, it is the correct averaging of the grades of the different elements of grading. Furthermore, I didn’t create the category...
There seems to be obvious wear but much remaining luster, I say AU55.
When the combination of luster, color, and associated eye appeal is far above the condition of the surfaces, the market grading of a coin is...
Separate names with a comma.
