It makes perfect sense to me and it is basically the same system I have been advocating for years. There are four elements of grading. Assign...
The TPGs are very tough on the 38-D Buffalo and they require outstanding luster and eye appeal for an MS67 grade. I think your coin has both but...
[img]
AN EXCLUSIVE ASSOCIATION OF PROFESSIONAL COIN DEALERS YOU CAN TRUST
[img] We need a dislike button for this thread, lots of nice coins, few monsters so far.
Net graded for an old cleaning and rim damage, no Bean
Excuse me, but, WHAT? Since when do fingerprints cause a "details" grade. I've seen MS66 and MS67s with obvious fingerprints.
I think I haven’t gotten a grade of a Buffalo Nickel correct in over a decade. MS63
That’s gorgeous, beaner
DLRC needs to fire their in-house photographer. No way they should be able to make an MS65 Peace Dollar look that bad.
MS64 DMPL
MS65 PL
MS65 DMPL
Hey, I know some dealers who use that strategy as their business model. But seriously, sometimes the details slab belongs in the trash. [IMG] [IMG]
Intuitively, I think this is correct, but so far, my anecdotal experience has shown me otherwise. I bought this Barber Half raw for AU money...
My dart hit MS64
I've never seen that color progression on a crescent toned Morgan Dollar before. The coin has both indicators of AT & NT, but it is a banged up...
MS63
Solid MS66
AU55
Separate names with a comma.
