I will give it a 1.5 because I like the pull away toning around the stars and date.
That 1964 is AT all day and PCGS should be embarrassed that they let that get through. That said, you guys have convinced me that the 1957 from...
Btw, here is that blue toned 1949-D I was referring to earlier in the thread. [img]
I actually like that green label, wish it was their normal color.
Yeah, you have convinced me, that 57-D is going to PCGS with my next submission. I will probably send the 57 to NGC since the surfaces aren't...
Correct me if I am wrong, but isn't the coin side of Jhon E Cash website handled by Brandon Kelley (formerly of Anaconda Rare Coins)? I remember...
Thanks buddy, you just saved me $25.
It's not that all the coins were AT, it was that whomever assembled this collection obviously didn't know the difference between NT and AT and...
The 57-D is nuclear toned in violet and pink and is 100% AT IMO. Most toned 57-Ds come from mint sets and they don't look like that at all....
+1
Well Brandon stated that he punished his scores because he doesn't like the EOR patterns. Personally, I love them and think their rarity in...
The 56-D & 57-D are not market acceptable and would definitely grade QT by PCGS and NGC. The 1957 has a shot a grading but considering the number...
How do you know if you qualify?
I wouldn't go that far. I had coin #2 at 4.8 and you had it at 5.0, that is pretty close. The only reason I had coin #1 a full point lower is...
The vast majority of the respondents to this thread and poll think this coin is either NT or MA. Now what if I told you this coin came from an...
Coin #1: 3.8 Coin #2: 4.8 My difference is based solely on the disparity in vibrancy between the two coins. The both have similar pattern and...
It doesn't, the toning is really deep, it mutes the luster and the strike is awful. IMO, the first coin outperforms #2 in every are with maybe...
Is the toning on the 1957 Jefferson Nickel shown below natural, artificial, or something in between? Please vote in the attached poll to express...
Ok, this is a dead heat, let's see if this changes any minds. [img]
That’s a 6
Separate names with a comma.
