In brg5658's world, this coin shown above is "highly toned" while the Buffalo shown below is "barely toned." And btw, my score of 1.0 was a...
You can offer your opinion, just make sure it is plausible. Your assertion that the Buffalo Nickel I posted is "barely toned" is ludicrous, and...
Actually, NO, the toned proof Jefferson Nickels from the 60's don't need a specific angle to see the toning. Many proof coins do need the angles...
Resorting to "I know you are but what am I" huh? I did rate that shilling as a 1.0 because I didn't think very much of the toning and most...
Again, stop whining, you are the only one who can't see the color in those photos.
I don't care about the spread or his low score, but saying that coin is "barely toned" is just factually inaccurate.
The 60's toned proof Jefferson's are striking. Heck, even V Kurt Bellman likes them, and he is a toning hating Wiemar White fan. I have owned...
In fairness, there really isn't that big of a spread in the scoring. wxcoin: 5.5 ddddd: 4.0 Morgandude11: 5.0 Lehigh96: 4.5 All of these...
You guys have convinced me, I’m keeping #2. The first coin is overgraded and coin #2 simply fits better in my registry set which is based on...
Can we get some photos of that Buffalo you bought?
Oh, so now it is “lightly toned” as opposed to “barely toned” huh? And yes, the entire reverse is toned. The reverse isn’t rainbow toned, but it...
That coin is amazing! MS67
Golden toning, Gold foil holder, deserves a gold sticker!
I agree Sy, the toning is quite attractive for a 51-S but nowhere near star worthy. And this coin is totally maxed out at MS67. It just seems...
Please guess the grade of the 1949 Franklin Half Dollar shown below. I have attached a poll for you to cast your vote and you may select up to 4...
No, the photos display a fully toned obverse in pastel shades of yellow, pink, and green. You can call the language flowery in an attempt to...
I feel like the TPG is causing my angst for coin 1 and my own head is causing me angst for coin 2. Not one person in this thread has made any...
Sure thing, I'm gonna contact the guy I sold it to 5 years ago and ask him if I can have it back so you can see better photos. It isn't my...
Yeah, they both give me that feeling, so wouldn't it be prudent to stick with the coin that everyone is likes? I think it is universal that Coin...
This is from that group, are you suggesting that I send this to PCGS "as is"?
Separate names with a comma.
