This is my most recent example, just got it back from PCGS today. [IMG] [IMG]
This is not my favorite coin or my favorite color scheme but it is still tremendous. 4.7
These graded Lincoln Cents on IG look more questionable than the OP’s. https://www.instagram.com/p/CIeNgoOjueX/?igshid=1pw8e8pv43l05
Maybe we can get an opinion from someone who collects toned Lincoln Cents about the originality of the toning. @robec are you out there?
I don’t think the dipping is the reason for the details grade. There are some small hairlines strewn about the surfaces of the coin, and NGC...
Thats because technical grading ignores several aspects of grading included in market grading. It is a more simple process, stands to reason...
If there was an exam with only one question: Is there a correct answer? I could fill two blue books.
I've found the opposite to be true.
I agree, those are the two problem areas that I see related to color scheme, but the yellow-green color is common enough and the elevation...
+1 Unless that coin comes back MS67* and is registry quality, I don't see it selling for $300 even in a slab. There are a lot of people in this...
I say NGC, should get a star designation.
Sesquis are usually butt ugly, yours is very attractive and should command a premium price for the assigned grade.
Most of them have a look that is market acceptable, but the problem with Roosevelt Dimes is that unless they are premium gem, nobody wants them,...
Whose registry set? Mumu’s?
6.5 In Peace Dollar terms, that is basically an unimprovable monster.
While I agree with your overall point that grades are not fixed, I don’t know how much the graders mood really factors into the equation. I have...
Skip, the word gimmick carries a negative connotation. As long as you use that word to describe the registries, people will continue to think you...
The PCGS Registry doesn’t use points, they just use average grade. Is their registry also a gimmick? The use of points allows NGC to weight the...
So because you don't need it to be happy, that makes it a "gimmick." I view the registry as an invaluable tool to organize and display my...
Why did the obverse suffer underwater corrosion, but the reverse remain unharmed? Very cool coin btw!
Separate names with a comma.
