I may be wrong, but it looks to me like it may have just been smashed with a couple of other coins. The other "strikes" look incuse like from...
If it is dated 1862 it is definitely a fake. If dated 1861 it is most likely a replica, a chance it is a restrike, and an almost impossibly small...
No real way to answer this for someone else, it is an individual preference thing. You need to collect what you like. Do you like silver? or...
Separate names with a comma.
