[ATTACH]
Improper cleaning. Probably many years ago.
[ATTACH] [ATTACH]
Type of 1856 [ATTACH] [ATTACH]
I will guess $8 before fees.
I went with 66. I'm thinking most of the marks were there when the coin was struck.
Fun thread. I sometimes get a coin in change with killer luster but the hits mess it up.
I would follow your dad's wishes and split it exactly even on each type of item. You might also ask the sisters to get with you if they decide to...
I don't think it's an S. That seller would have caught that and listed it as such.
@ToughCOINS found this and thought of me. He took the images as well. [ATTACH] [ATTACH]
Keep in mind that PCGS won't grade the coin. They may put it in a details slab. Nice coin.
Not a chance. Please post full images of the coin.
Sorry but your coin is not an MS. It's AU at best.
Nice set. Many look MS to me. What grade do you think on the 1924. Looks like some nice luster under the toning.
Yes, you are correct.
I have to agree with MS-60. Just too many marks. Great images.
I though that as well but it's not in the correct spot based on the reverse images.
Separate names with a comma.