Really? Is that your expert opinion? Do yourself a favor dude, don't offer me advice on any subject. You are not qualified, and I'm not interested.
No better indictment of the premium gem grade than that comment right there.:cigar:
Perhaps PCGS is considering the chatter remnant planchet flaws. I don't know how they would justify that either given the strike, but hey, it is...
Not sure how PCGS can justify an MS66 grade with the condition of the shield on the reverse, the obverse color not withstanding.
I gotta tell ya, I think Greg's photos are actually emphasizing the flaws on some of your coins. I was two grades low on both of the Walkers that...
I am pretty sure that some of my Jefferson Nickels are AT. I don't want bad AT, I want good AT, from a skilled coin doctor.
Uh, I don't know how, need someone else to do it for me. Is there a doctor in the house? A coin doctor?
I want a rainbow toned example. Is it wrong to artificially tone a fantasy coin?
I don't know how to put this, but asking us if you overpaid on a $15 coin purchase is...... Well I don't know what it is but it makes me wanna...
Then I implore you to look at the photo again and reconsider your grade.
Coin looks dipped and retoned from a Dansco album. The luster looks okay but there is some light hairlines on the obverse. They don't scream...
Frank, I have owned a gem grade 44-s before. This coin aint that! I was torn between AU58 and MS62. I know the 44-S is known for a poor strike.
MS64
AU58
That coin doesn't have the look of a gem Morgan to me at all. I am going to go conservative with this one and say MS63. To the OP, a few things....
The question of whether to submit to NGC or PCGS comes up frequently. And the answer is both. It all depends on the coin. Some series you are...
What are your grade predictions Matt?
It is really hard to tell from those photos but I think I see some high point rub on the obverse. Either AU58 if there is friction, or MS62 if...
The last one I sold was not so good. [IMG]
Separate names with a comma.
