My initial impression is low MS. It has a mediocre luster based on the photos, a fair amount of bag marks, and isn't overly attractive. MS63
They grade millions of coins, of course it will happen. My point was that it is rare, while everyone else seems to want to make the extreme...
I’m sure there are a few out there, my point is that they are rare.
I’m not talking about CAC stickers , I’m talking about multiple grade bumps upon resubmission outside rainbow toned coins or coins that came from...
Starting to sound like a company man.
I know I have!
I’ve already proven that isn’t true. You can’t apply the antiquated ANA standards to the TPGs who don’t use them.
The fact that nobody has shown an example of an untoned coin getting a multiple point bump upon resubmission indicates there is no proof.
I don't know why they gave that coin a green sticker, it is plainly obvious that the coin was a much higher grade than MS65, and even the TPGs...
I wish more people thought this way. This is how gradeflation really happens. We see coins all the time that have attributes of 2 different...
In your earlier post (above in red), you were quite clear that negative eye appeal should act as a grade limiter and prevent a gem grade. Now you...
That coin is an enigma and isn’t representative of TPG grading or CACs consistency. People need to chill out.
Wait, wait, wait... Are you talking about rainbow toned coins? Or are saying there are untoned coins with CAC greens that are getting 1.5 point...
For Example: [img] or [img] or [img] And all of these examples are from the first page of Heritage's 1880-S MS67 archive. None of these...
You also said that coins with excellent strike, Luster, and surface preservation will naturally have good eye appeal. The Barber Quarters I...
Holy necro thread!
Classic commems don’t usually have many marks and the grades are very luster dependent. I guessed MS66 because of the eye appeal but the assigned...
Number 4 is like the Energizer Bunny, still going!
I’m not sure that was intentional, but even if it was accidental from improper storage, the coin is still a problem coin in my view and is not...
Which two? The ones with CAC stickers? No doubt that ugly coins sell for less and pretty coins sell for more. The question is should eye...
Separate names with a comma.
