The 1958 is an absolute bear. These are about as good as they get. I've never seen a 58-P that blew me away, NEVER!
Lol, I'm not going that far, but it certainly is dreck.
I think the inconsistency of the star designation is directly related to training within the ranks of the NGC grading team. It wouldn’t surprise...
Those shaving nicks are actually remnant planchet flaws and don’t affect the grade. That said, the strike is really weak, even for a 58-P, and it...
100% deserves a star
Ok, so here is where we are at. The vote is currently 16-0 for the first coin which is ungraded and the second coin is graded by NGC [IMG] The...
Of the two 1958 Jefferson Nickels show below, which one do you prefer? Please explain your reasons why in the comments. COIN #1 [img] [img]...
Probably not, I’m never gonna be happy with a coin that has MS66 surfaces that is graded MS67 despite how beautiful the toning is. I will...
Nobody is disputing that the second coin is better, but it still has marks. One on the bridge of the nose, one on the shoulder and a bunch more...
Do us a favor and post both of the Great Collections photos for each coin side by side so we can see an apples to apples comparison.
Because you are looking at two different types of photos. My photos are designed to show the actual appearance of the coin, including marks. The...
Of course it should
You guys are a little harsh on this coin. The luster and eye appeal are off the charts and the surfaces despite the marks on the cheek are still...
Don't ask me how, but this coin does not have a star. [img]
Any more guesses? I will reveal later today.
MS62
C’mon man, give me some credit. I would never have even submitted this coin for grading. I got it with bad photos for a good price (or so I...
How did you get this? And do you agree with the grade?
C’mon NGC, this is absolute freaking dreck! [IMG] This is high end 64 or low end 65 but no way is this full steps. I’m seriously considering...
Bag marks have nothing to do with the star designation. They lower the numerical grade but are not considered when evaluating for the star...
Separate names with a comma.
