I see no evidence whatsoever that the coin has been "whizzed"; lightly cleaned or dipped, but not "whizzed". I see many people use that term in...
It's a very common coin in low grade Unc. or AU58 condition and as such, there is not a lot of demand for it. Depending upon the coin in question,...
In that case, it doesn't strike me as a particularly "good price" even if it is MS60. By the way, I would hope that if he had priced it a lot...
I think so, though images often don't show problems that can be seen in-hand. What do you consider a "good price"? And don't forget about any...
That might just be a typical soft strike on the eagle's breast - it's hard to tell about that (and, due to the lighting, the grade) from the...
I have no doubt that it does.
While NGC's language might sound harsh and overly broad, they won't be penalizing innocent parties. They are unquestionably aiming at those who...
You might very well be correct. But if he cared and asked, I could provide him with plenty of proof.
I doubt it will have any impact on the seller, but just sent the following message to him through EBay: "Congratulations, hundreds of people are...
Thanks for the thread - I think it's a good idea and hope that others agree and will participate. You might consider changing the thread title...
There's nothing wrong with opinions, it's just that they're more meaningful if they're based on facts. The subject matter in the link you...
Comparing a classic silver commemorative isue (with no history of milk spots) to modern commemoratives or ASE's with a history of milk spots is an...
Thanks guys.
If you did not already do so, please report it to Ebay. I did, but the more, the better. Here's a link for reporting - thanks:...
We don't know how the true appearance of the coin differed from its image. And you can obviously have and share your opinion that the coin "will...
Actually, based on the ("after") images, my guess is that the coin is one of those which displays a semi-prooflike appearance and is quite...
The imaged coin looks like a harshly cleaned business strike and doesn't give any indication of having been struck as a Proof.
Hopefully, I'm just seeing haze and not artificial frosting or wiping on the coin. Images often don't tell the real story. Still, I'd suggest...
Thanks, I had misunderstood and thought he was speaking of the PCGS forum. That said, I must still respectfully disagree with him.:)
The marks on Liberty's face and neck lead me to go with MS62 and I can't imagine that the coin would grade above MS63. Hopefully Liberty's cheek...
Separate names with a comma.
