I don't own a Pilgrim (they don't come Prooflike), but here's an Indian: [ATTACH] [ATTACH]
Yes, in numismatics, "scarce" is more common than "rare." There are many, many different rarity scales used, some more useful than others. This...
This particular coin is damaged. It looks like they were trying to counterfeit an error.
Gonna go NT on the Columbian. Has the look of having been stored in tissue paper or something like that for a hundred years.
To anyone who knows, or anyone who spends 3 minutes researching, that is clearly counterfeit. It is a good copy, but very definitely fake. But...
Well, he has an extensive list of interesting things. Gonna have to spend some time perusing that candy-store!
I agree, that Lafayette is low grade but it sure is something special! Great eye appeal on that piece.
20 years later and the guy offered a full refund? Someone link his website so I can go buy something. That is well beyond what I would have expected.
He clearly states it is a replica, several times. I wouldn't say it's nearly as horrible as many other listings that try to pass it off as the...
Two basic reasons: MS-70 is often applied with a Q-tip instead of submerging the coin. And, the MS-70 colors more often affect the patinated areas...
As a counterpoint to Rick's thread above, I present to you one of those collector's experiments, fully documented with pictures, showing the...
Rick Snow is extremely knowledgeable - but you have to remember that, as a dealer, he also has an agenda. I've been following this topic for a...
The IHC is absolutely AT. That blue and purple color comes from treatment with MS-70. While many people like the look, I find it off-putting and...
Hard pass - avoid that one. It is ugly, damaged, and an eyesore. 1824 half dollars are common enough that you don't need to settle for something...
If I felt that strongly about the customer service, I probably would have asked to speak to a manager and let him know how poorly the attendant...
I think a QT response should fall on the AT side of the spectrum, and a MA response should fall on the NT side. Realistically, there are many more...
Roger W. Burdette. His username on several forums is RWB. He is the author of "The Renaissance of American Coinage", "From Mine to Mint" and many...
Jcro, you only have to mention the company or the person, and people loose their minds. Me included.
I was hoping to avoid this in this thread, but your laudatory post sang his praises just a bit too much. Comparing him to the criminal Omega seems...
Wut? I totally missed that! Can you show us alternate pictures that show the wear? I'm not seeing it in your original pics.
Separate names with a comma.
