Points Table ddddd - 8 Points Beefer518 - 7 Points brg5658 - 7 Points baseball21 - 6.5 Points IBetASilverDollar - 5 Points heavycam.monstervam - 5...
Here is a coin I purchased to crack out for my type set. Greysheet bid is $235 for a generic XF 40 Trade Dollar. Via Heritage I found that...
$425 ...great colors; I'm guessing that you got a good deal and that it would go for more via the correct auction (or buy-it-now) setting.
Points Table ddddd - 8 Points Beefer518 - 7 Points baseball21 - 6.5 Points brg5658 - 6 Points IBetASilverDollar - 5 Points heavycam.monstervam - 5...
There is also an ongoing thread for deals that anyone can add to:...
Points Table ron_c - 3 Points KSorbo - 1 Point IBetASilverDollar - 1 Point charlietig - 1 Point Beefer518 - 1 Point jwitten - 1 Point ddddd - 1...
I think 45 was a pretty good price. You could likely sell it for more. Nice find!
60 This one looks more hazy/splotchy than I personally like. I would not consider it to have much of a premium, but I do think some may like it....
115 The reverse really pops, but the obverse looks a bit more splotchy...I still like it!
I agree; I have stopped (the original paging was from early on; the thread started in July).
The photos are pretty accurate...on the reverse there are a few lines that might be from a light cleaning or die polish lines (they can only be...
Update: no bean! CAC didn't like it even as a 55!
625 ...the scratch does not look that bad Thanks @Santinidollar
AU 58...looks nice enough to be MS 63 on a good day
@baseball21 what is guide for a straight graded Fine (i.e. F12)?
PCI -> MS 63 My take -> AU 55 Some PCI holders are decent or even accurate, but the gold ones are fairly often too high.
Buffalo Nickels sure aren't as simple as Morgans when it come to grading! I will go with my first impression: MS 64
I agree that Buffalo Nickels are hard to grade. I would not be surprised with anything between AU and MS....I will go with my first impression: MS 63
I sold it for $57 so @baseball21 barely nudges out @ron_c ..that person then put it up on ebay raw and made another $10-$15; I later saw it from...
Separate names with a comma.
