Well I do not know what coin you are bidding on, but I hope you lose. Typically SGS does over grade and is not looked on too nicely here. Of...
Man - maybe my eyes are shot, but I can't tell wear from distorted picture. So maybe AU or MS, maybe clean or not cleaned, maybe brown or red....
Well I certainly do not agree with those grades, but oh well! I can certainly see corrosion on that first coin. Even the auction I pointed to...
Okay - I understand where you are saying about the coin. Still a really nice coin!
That is completely different and a much nicer. So I think XF would work for that coin.
Only one - but he was a seller. The only negative I have ever given and received. I would not even consider his request to withdraw the negative....
Okay I see what you are saying - I looked at some more 1821's on heritage and they do seem to be darker.
But wouldn't a weak strike result fewer details on the high points? And thus the slight run just breaks the luster, but not really create true...
Okay - I have to ask - why do you think the last one was cleaned? I see the different colors around the stars, but I can not see for sure that it...
Well - I personally think PCGS was accurate. You have a combined weak strike with little wear on the high points only. The only real breaks in...
My personal opinion is F details - cleaned but re-toning.
I did not stop to think - did you mean proof sets or singles? Actually now that I think about either way I have more than 90, unless of course...
Ummm - you don't need to store them cause you could just throw them away. :)
Looks like you guys did pretty good. I overpaid for 1941 and 1941-S wheatie, but the $50 made the prices reasonable.
I don't get it either - why try to hide part of the holder and then describe the coin as cleaned. The holders look real to me and maybe they are...
I think he suggested a local dealer so you could see some MS graded Morgans in hand. That is vastly different than trying to buy using pictures...
Seems like you all get some good deals - me the best I did was in the lots section I won a 1944(P-D-S) wheaties NGC 66RD for 36 with SH&I. Saved...
You can see the first coin on heritage.
Coin 1 I would say is VF details(cleaned and porous looking). Coin 2 I would say is VF20(probably graded VF30) - I don't like the ding in front...
Please show patience when using ebay! Don't let the "I need one" get the better of you. More coins, especially the common date coins, will...
Separate names with a comma.
