I have one more and then @Lehigh96 I believe has one. Does this Morgan deserve a star? [ATTACH] And a video:...
Summary: Rd. 1: 1955-S MS 64 1c (NO Star) --> Should it star? -->Yes: 2 vs No: 11 Totals: No Star currently on holder, but deserves it: 0 No...
That was my guess as well for the no star. It’s interesting how decisive this has been so far vs the replies in the AT/NT thread:...
Star thread is here: https://www.cointalk.com/threads/to-star-or-not-to-star-official-game-thread.332059/
@Lehigh96 @jtlee321 @heavycam.monstervam Tag more people so we can get this thread going. :)
First up: should this coin receive a star? [ATTACH] [ATTACH]
After looking through a bunch of NGC coins, one will realize a special feature that they use-the Star designation. Here you can see some info...
This one is looking like it's about to be over, but let's give a few more people a chance to comment on the Lincoln. @EyeAppealingCoins @Pickin...
Would there be any interest in a thread where we all judge NGC stars (probably toning only) to see if the majority of posters feels a Star coin is...
I'm stumped as well (all I can see is lowest Philly mintage for their respective decades, but that can't be it).
Next up is this Lincoln Cent: [IMG] [IMG]
Here's one that sold on eBay for $380 @Ike Skywalker would you classify this one in the AT camp? [IMG] [IMG] [IMG]...
I agree with you that this one does not look natural. However, the TPGs let quite a few of these through (so they considered them acceptable)....
MS 64 FBL ...I cannot tell for sure about FBL from the photo, but I suspect it was graded FBL
Those colors look striking and would garner a decent premium. I do suspect these have been assisted at some point but the TPGs have allowed some...
Sometimes that is best to prevent mistyping. The rabbit doesn’t always win the race. :D
Floor is open...
It was 63 when he made that post...now it’s lower since more posts have been made.
He edited the comment after I posted my original reply.
Even if he paid retail, it still suggests that a supposed doctor was successful (if it was AT). The coin didn’t sell for a discount. Many would...
Separate names with a comma.
