The last one was the only one that looked undergraded at 65+ ....at 68 it's certainly maxed out. Four of the five only received a green sticker...
I missed seeing this one in time. It looked a point better than the previous Morgan (based on being less baggy). I graded that one 62, so my grade...
The 68 would almost certainly be two grades lower. The others would be lower too. The first example (65+ to 67) has a few reeding marks on the...
Most looked to be correct, and had the green CAC as evidence (besides the 65+ which CACed at 65+ and 67+). Some might have even started in lower...
Here is a recent example of a big color bump: https://www.cointalk.com/threads/guess-the-grade-morgan-toner.344695/ This thread also has some...
And for the 3c, I’m guessing the Anacs holder caused it to go low... -$250 -MS 63 at PCGS
My mistake... @Mainebill you were closest in the last round Edited: Points table: ddddd - 39.26 Points Beefer518 - 31.26 Points baseball21 -...
Well then I'll double down on my original 62 vote. :p
@ToughCOINS did anything change with this one? I didn't vote as I remember the answer.
I voted VF 35 ....I believe at least a trace of luster is needed for XF (but maybe that's just me reading Insider's posts from how grading used to...
I went with MS 63 (looks like nice luster but some marks, like that reverse hit)...I also think these are hard to grade, so it'll be interesting...
Points table: ddddd - 39.26 Points Beefer518 - 31.26 Points baseball21 - 26.61 Points heavycam.monstervam - 23.51 Points Duke Kavanaugh - 23.51...
Yes I have a similar mindset as what @Murphy45p described. Here is a link to my thread where a good deal of coins came from details holders (or...
25
If it has sentimental value, just put it in a flip (maybe mark it as 'Dad's Dollar) and leave it as is. If you don't mind experimenting with it,...
They are all nice, but I would not count on any receiving a star. I have seen some like this with a star and others without one. Even with the...
@Paddy54 you're next... Points table: ddddd - 39.26 Points Beefer518 - 31.26 Points baseball21 - 26.61 Points heavycam.monstervam - 23.51 Points...
$100
66 ...looks clean throughout but average eye appeal (at least from my interpretation of the photos) prevents a higher grade
Small White Anacs holder? I voted 65 PL....photos appear to show the PL qualities....a few marks at the bottom of the cheek, below the S of...
Separate names with a comma.
