I could believe it. It's hard to imagine how that could be, but there are so many examples that make one wonder. It would be nice if NGC went in...
Summary: Rd. 1: 1955-S MS 64 1c (NO Star) --> Should it star? -->Yes: 2 vs No: 11 Rd. 2: 1885-O MS 65 $1 (NO Star) —>Should it star? —> Yes: 4 vs...
You don't. The populations are good for knowing relatively how many of each is graded. However, the crossovers and crackouts make numbers...
I'm going to buck the trend and say NO Star It's a nice coin, but the spot between the A and B on the obverse sticks out to me and it seems that...
It seems that they define chop marks as coming from the Orient. There are quite a few different ones and I wouldn't be surprised if this is also...
I'm also a NO on the half cent (same reason as Mainebill...the spots stuck out immediately and i'm thinking it lacks luster; the lack of luster...
You can post as soon as you're ready. (I'm not going to count the 50-D 67 star that I posted as it was more of a discussion related to the prior...
As far I know, Anacs will also call it details. ICG now straight grades them too (from what I have seen in the newer blue label holders).
PCGS straight grades them while NGC will give a details grade.
I like it! Edit: grade guess...MS 63
Anyone?
Some of those 70s and 80s MS 66s were overgraded by quite a bit. Many people guessed under 66 there as well. And I called one of them a 64 (so it...
Here it is copied over from the star thread. And I was comparing the GC photos when saying the star is 1-1.5 pts nicer....
I was comparing the two using the same GC photos and to me the 67 star was a superior coin. The mark on the non-star is in an area of the obverse...
Green ...it looks acceptable for a 65 (not PQ in my opinion, but at least "B" level).
So I mentioned there being two of these, here is the other 1950-D nickel that was originally in the same auction. Should it star? [IMG] [IMG]
When I was bidding on the coin that @Lehigh96 posted, I was also bidding on the coin below. Both had the same grade, but to me this coin looked to...
It might just be the photos, but the areas around the letters (especially on the reverse) looks like evidence of cleaning. That was what made me...
@geekpryde you are up... followed by Wxcoin and then ldhair
Separate names with a comma.
