Wow, your arrogance knows no boundaries does it? You still after all this time present your opinion as an incontrovertible fact. You have not...
I will go along with that, but I would like to see photos with better lighting and not at an angle before I commit to a grade assessment.
Doug, Do you think I argue with you just for the sake of arguing with you? When you make a post that is incorrect, I feel compelled to point...
I have explained my opinion regarding gradeflation before and we have had this discussion before. I freely admit that gradeflation exists but I...
In my opinion, Doug is 100% correct. The toning on these coins would drive little to no premium.
You have me a little confused. You grade the coin AU58 but make no mention of any wear on the coin. Toning does not equate to wear and the lines...
IMO, Mike's assessment of the grade is spot on! That said, it does not look out of place in an MS65 holder, but no way does this coin ever...
Please guess the grade of this 1922-D Peace Dollar graded by NGC in the attached poll. [img] Comments about the coin and your reason behind...
How about showing me an example of a coin that bears a mint state grade but has obvious wear from circulation. Are you claiming to not have...
1) I agree 2) I agree 3) I agree and have posted the reasons why in threads that you were an active member. Do you know the reasons why it...
Well so much for gradeflation. Here is a coin graded by NGC over a decade ago that all but a handfull of collectors thought would be at most an...
I don't own grading books that are that old!
Byron, The coin is AU58, there is some high point wear. And I don't consider roll friction an option for the Jefferson series. However, my...
If what Doug has been posting was crap, then your post was pure sewage!
So now you want us to check the old threads. Well thanks to Shane, we don't have to. Shane just resurrected this thread that started in 2003 on...
WOW! The three quoted above are my favorites. That Barber Half is just sick. I don't think most people understand how hard it is to find...
Well, honestly, I have no idea if the coin is good for the grade or not. I know that the surfaces are clean enough, but those photos tell me...
Be sure to look for one of these! [img] [img] 1939 Doubled Monticello Jefferson Nickel
Due to the commonality of mint set toners from 1957 & 1958 and the fact that the mottling on the obverse would turn off a lot of potential buyers,...
Are you worried that it falls short of 5FS? I have learned not to distrust NGC with regards to the FS designation. I am confident that my photos...
Separate names with a comma.
