And it really doesn't because the standards for a 1929 vs 1928-S are very different with regards to strike. Here is a 1928-S SLQ PCGS MS66 FH CAC...
That is not an apt analogy Chris, and you know it! Wow, this is exactly the mentality that I was talking about earlier. I don't care how long...
I prefer [ATTACH]
The missing silver proofs reside in PCGS PR70 DCAM slabs. [IMG] Oh yeah, I like the flags. My father used to collect flags. [IMG]...
I feel the need to make one more point. Just because the membership might be less knowledgeable doesn't mean that Cointalk is an inferior forum....
If you have experience collecting premium gem SLQ's, then prove it. And why do you find it necessary to compose your posts in a forum chat...
If you were a member of either of those forums you would understand why I think the members of those forums are more knowledgeable collectors....
I am not trying to win, just offering a dissenting opinion to your own. And as an aspiring coin cataloger, I would characterize it as a "speckeld...
The PCGS standard for MS66 Eye Appeal is: And while you find this coin horribly ugly, I think your opinion is in the minority. Even if the...
Please don't phrase it that way. A CAC sticker does not mean the coin has above average eye appeal and does not equate to attractiveness. It...
You can't compare strikes across different dates/mm. The 1929 had an above average strike while the 1928-S had a below average strike. Almost...
Here is a link to the Heritage Glossary: Heritage Coin Glossary Here is a link to the NGC Glossary: NGC Coin Glossary
That is as cool as the other side of the pillow!
Your hatred of the toning is clouding your judgement. Have NCS dip it, you might like it better. As for the strike, that was not a well struck...
Actually, NO, I didn't. At least not with the intent you are claiming. I was working on my response to your comment in another thread,...
Good point Lance, I find the level of opposition to third party grading on this forum to be hysterical. Why don't we see that same level of...
OMG, if that isn't the pot calling the kettle black!
The responses in this thread are evidence of only one thing, that nobody here has ever collected premium gem SLQ's. That coin is properly graded...
Mike, I don't collect proof Jeffersons. Do they show remnant planchet flaws like their mint state counterparts? If they don't, I am not...
The reason we argue is because we disagree on a great many things related to numismatics. It is not because I don't listen. And for you to...
Separate names with a comma.
