Based on your situation, I'd recommend selling. Take a look at recent sales for some data. Then list both at a fairly strong number (buy-it-now)...
Adding on to my post, the decision to sell should involve a few factors: (1) do you need the money now? (2) can you put the proceeds of the sale...
I recall we discussed these on the toning threads and the AT/NT threads (especially the first one, which has some question marks but is beautiful...
You did well and this was the perfect coin to experiment with (it was at the point where even if it was ruined, you wouldn't be losing...
I'd probably start it at $1,400 and set $1,100 as the floor.
Blast white without CAC is between $950 and $1,000 lately....add CAC and you are closer to $1,250...add the color from yours and I would guess...
So maybe it's the first four tagged?
I could see it going at least 65. It looks like an attractive nickel! By the way @Pickin and Grinin the tag didn't work. I believe only three at...
I was too conservative here compared to PCGS and CAC. I don't have any issue with it being a 65.
Something made me think AU 58 :banghead: (hey at least I didn't call this one a proof:p)
Is it that rumor of CAC starting its own grading service?
MS 64 was my first impression (although I debated 65); I think PCGS was more conservative given some contact marks and the better date.
And I did mention semi-pl in my guess, so that counts for something right? :p I think you are right @jtlee321 that the reverse just held it back....
I was also thinking PCGS.
Glad to see I was low instead of high; that coin deserves the grade. Nice find!
And don't forget to account for shipping fees. That can add another chunk to your total.
I checked my work after posting, so now I know. :D
PR 65 ...without cheating (if I'm wrong, then you definitely know I did not look it up :p)
I'll say MS 66 here ....if it's a 65, then maybe the struck though portions clouded the grader's judgment :p
I'll go MS 65 PL ....I think the mirrors are strong enough to get the PL (otherwise it's a very nice semi-pl)...fields and cheek are relatively...
Separate names with a comma.
