XF details, scratched
I say F details, cleaned.
Honestly, I wouldn't even care if he didn't admit that the coins were AT. That color scheme (purple & blue) is a tell tale sign of an AT coin and...
So is it fair to say that you agree with the TPG application of market grading principles with regards to high point friction as it pertains to...
I think we should put you in full Jefferson Frenzy! [IMG] [IMG]
I wonder what kept if from 67, the weak strike (relatively), the pock mark on shoulder, or both? I think this coin probably gets MS67 from NGC....
I used to own a 40-D Mercury Dime with a very similar toning pattern. [IMG] Must have been Starbucks bold on mine.
You wrote the post above in October 2012 in this same thread. Based on what you are saying now, it would appear that Doug (et al) have convinced...
I agree!
So anyone who agrees with the TPG grading philosophy is wrong, but the handful of people who agree with you, know what they are talking about. Is...
This was a cool coin, but I sold it. [IMG]
Obverse: 1886 Morgan Dollar NGC MS64* Battle Creek Collection (Pink Eye Dollar) [IMG][IMG] Reverse: 1883-O Morgan Dollar NGC MS64* (Reverse...
You omitted the one object that is at the center of the debate. If you are calling it an innocent oversight, I will accept that given your...
The topic was brought up in the other thread that the OP posted about this coin. Since this is a heavily counterfeited coin, any raw 42/1 Mercury...
I will chill out when you stop trolling this forum. Btw, what is your fascination with the fact that I play poker?
Please refer to my comments in the other thread you created regarding this coin. Did you look at the reverse? Is the die scratch present?
Another ad hominem attack. Why am I obsessed, because I call you out for trolling someone's thread?
The diagnostic for the 1942/1 is on the reverse. All genuine examples will show a die scratch the connects the olive branch to the very bottom of...
You gonna give your opinion on the grade, or did you just stop by to drop a one liner?
I like #1
Separate names with a comma.