+1
This thread is EPIC! It started as another pot shot toning thread and turned into a crazy debate that has been going strong for over 30 pages...
I agree with you, but I think we need to get people to walk before we teach them to run.
I think the coin is on the borderline of QT and MA but I would like to see it in hand before passing judgement. The toning is not dramatic, and...
MS65
I just checked E-Bay and there are 87,156 PCGS and 68,346 NGC graded US coins, so Vic's 150K was actually rounded down. I then simply typed in...
So you were not a coin dealer, not a collector, but you continued to attend more shows than anyone else in the world until 2009? Are you a...
So you are saying that toned coins are more prevalent on the bourse floor than in auctions? I call that bluff! And what coin shows do you...
I gave you a chance to explain what you meant, you responded with a juvenile response that just quoted every previous response that you made to...
I already proved that you did infact "infer" it. If you don't have the integrity to admit when you are wrong, why should we believe anything that...
Actually, you were the one who inferred it! If you meant something else, we are all ears.
Toned coins are not that common, PERIOD. I watch every Heritage auction and have for over a decade. I look at all the Morgan Dollars and all the...
So your saying that the market is saturated with AT coins yet he happens to find the one auction in the US that is immune to such saturation. He...
That sounds difficult to me, not easy.
Showing a PCGS mistake is not tantamount to market saturation. In answer to your question, Kurt said it is not. He attended an auction and out...
Every coin is different, and that is part of my point. You can't predict which coins people will consider ugly, because opinions will vary just...
Lol, but you forgot the roll eyes emoji. Some members of this thread might actually think you are agreeing with them.
I never noticed that before, it does look like a clash. Unfortunately I can't take out my loupe and examine it because I sold the coin years ago....
The common date Morgan Dollars would be an easy choice for coin doctors to experiment on due to their affordability. They would also be the coins...
Nice post, but completely tangential to our conversation. I never even mentioned correct dipping methods. All I said was that the TPGs don't...
Separate names with a comma.
