I didn't miss that thread, it is about a circulated CBH which I have very little experience, so as I stated above, I refrained from comment. If...
When I disagree with the TPGs, I put my money where my mouth is; here is an example from 2012: Guess the Assigned Grade--1924 Standing Liberty...
What happens when a coin has MS63 surfaces and MS66 Luster? How do you weight each attribute. Both graders could accept that the surfaces were...
You know that isn't how market grading works, so stop trolling me with your little devil's advocate routine. And just where do you think the...
I saw the grade in the other thread, I can’t guess.
I forgot to post my 1958-D: [img] Really well struck, almost 6FS, and nice subtle toning with just miss surfaces.
Bought this last months in hopes to upgrade my album collection, but it was rather lack luster so I sold it. Still some nice toning though. [img]
I have no idea, I can't remember the last time I had a circulated Morgan Dollar. Not a dig at anyone, just a fact.
There is a big difference between net grading a coin that has "problems" rather than deeming the coin a problem coin and lower grades for dipping...
This was my initial impression as well, hence my questions, which the OP has yet to answer. Several posters think the coin is a DDO, and since I...
Wanna explain?
There is a huge difference between circulated and uncirculated coins. The elements of grading are surface preservation, strike, luster, and eye...
That’s awesome, is it graded?
Dude, you don’t get to change numismatic nomenclature. The term damage is reserved for problem coins. Wear is the natural result of circulation...
You need to get more light on the coin and fix your white balance. From those photos I’m at MS62. Why are you having this coin graded? What...
I don’t get in that many fights!
I loved Rueben, he was fun!
No, that is your reason, and it is completely arbitrary. I don’t want two coins with nearly identical surfaces grade the same if one has premium...
They don’t use technical grading, they employ market grading where luster and eye appeal are factored into the grade. Why do you use a system...
While I wish that was true, the fact is that each individual grader is going to have their own bias which will seep into the grading process even...
Separate names with a comma.
