Yes, we all agree that eye appeal will increase the price of the coin, but that isn't the crux of the argument. He contends that coins should be...
I made the winning argument that the pretty patina actually changed the condition/grade of the coin and it is that improvement in condition/grade...
MS67 $650
It’s not easy to buy a circulated 50-D either. I’ve only ever owned one AU example.
dup post
Actually, Jefferson Nickels is near impossible to complete in circulated condition, because the 1950-D was so widely hoarded its almost impossible...
Okay, this is where I pivot and defend the TPG grade at all costs, blaming photos, lack of in hand inspection, marks are magnified etc.... NOPE,...
MS64+*
For some series of coins, this disparity is warranted. PCGS is at least 1/2 point more conservative on their grading of Jefferson Nickels, yet...
Binion coins have their own separate collecting group in addition to the rainbow toner collectors. My guess is you had to pay up for this one. $375
Come on Bill, that’s a low blow, you know I don’t own the coin. I think you should go back and re-read that thread. You were the one who first...
Because none of those other people who graded this coin MS63, graded the 1885-S MS63. From my perspective, there is just no reasonable...
Who do you blame for this? IMO, the obvious scapegoat would be Legend.
Even if I am starting an argument, that is the nature of dissent. He makes his argument, I make mine, and the readers decide who they think is...
My thoughts exactly.
+1
I will post whatever opinion I want within the boundary of forum rules. The point of my most recent post was to illustrate that his assigned...
Do you have any other photos than the PCGS Truview? @ToughCOINS read the photo correctly and guessed to correct grade. For those of us with less...
So you grade this coin an MS63+, but the 1885-S from the previous thread was an MS63?????? Thank you so much, I love a good laugh in the morning.
I’m obviously not on ignore if you are responding to my posts, making you a LIAR! Are you a moderator? If not, it isn’t your job to intervene to...
Separate names with a comma.
