NGC probably would have at least given it a star.
Part of the reason may be supply and demand. Morgans have been a popular collector coin. I think the GSA sales a few decades ago stirred up...
It depends on what ran over it. If it was a 4884 Big Boy then it may be worth more.
In the end it should be what the buyer likes, regardless the grade or whether it has a star. Unfortunately, for those building registry sets, a...
I find this thread interesting as to what others define as star worthy. As I said earlier, toning to me is in the eye of the beholder so...
So you don't believe in time travel?
Separate names with a comma.