+1
Well Brandon stated that he punished his scores because he doesn't like the EOR patterns. Personally, I love them and think their rarity in...
The 56-D & 57-D are not market acceptable and would definitely grade QT by PCGS and NGC. The 1957 has a shot a grading but considering the number...
How do you know if you qualify?
I wouldn't go that far. I had coin #2 at 4.8 and you had it at 5.0, that is pretty close. The only reason I had coin #1 a full point lower is...
The vast majority of the respondents to this thread and poll think this coin is either NT or MA. Now what if I told you this coin came from an...
Coin #1: 3.8 Coin #2: 4.8 My difference is based solely on the disparity in vibrancy between the two coins. The both have similar pattern and...
It doesn't, the toning is really deep, it mutes the luster and the strike is awful. IMO, the first coin outperforms #2 in every are with maybe...
Is the toning on the 1957 Jefferson Nickel shown below natural, artificial, or something in between? Please vote in the attached poll to express...
Ok, this is a dead heat, let's see if this changes any minds. [img]
That’s a 6
Yes, NGC also has the + grade. PCGS is harsher on numerical grade, and NGC is tougher on 5FS, but this coin is a no brainer 5FS, so you are...
4.2 There is that blue/violet color scheme again that isn’t my favorite.
That coin is gem full steps all day. If you are already sending coins to NGC, might as well include this one under the modern tier. I have a...
Wow, this is very close!
Shown below are two uncirculated 1955 Jefferson Nickels. Please vote in the attached poll indicating which coin your prefer and if you feel like...
Nobody is telling you not to enjoy the coin, but you seem rather new to this so we are trying to help you avoid the pitfalls that ensnare newer...
I'm at a 5.1. The toning breaks bother me a little, especially the area on the cap, and I don't really understand this toning pattern. The coin...
I am rating them subjectively. I’m not partial to blanket blue toning, and the unique toning on this coin with the elevation chromatics boosted...
You guys are gonna be surprised by this, but I actually prefer proof coins to be untoned and find toning like that to be distracting.
Separate names with a comma.
