@49ers, can you take another picture showing the coin? I'm in a sarcastic mood and almost typed "great caramel, wood toning"?
Still having a hard time grading from those pictures. It does appear to be very clean of contact marks. But, I can call a coin About...
I don't know whether how these toned, but I'm not a fan of the bullseye toning. I hope it works out for you. Are you planning on flipping them?
I've been a repeat buyer from a particular seller. I won 3 items from him recently that closed on the same day. I paid for each individually....
That's a 1889-O. Selling in that grade at HA for around $3200. I've bought from that seller before and was pleased. I'm wondering if they...
Very nice Geek! Some good advice above! It's really up to you whether you want the attribution on the label. If you ever go to sell it, you can...
Those are completely over-graded and I think you should sell me the 1801! <wink, wink>. Great coins Chief. I'd love to add either of those to...
Here's my latest. I mentioned in the "newest acquisitions" thread why I bought this coin. The luster is much stronger in-hand. While not...
I thought part of the fun of filling an album is being able to pick/choose each coin to your satisfaction. I understand the album came with 117...
So what did this actually grade?
I like the toning on the coin. I didn't look at the NGC site, but I also think it's AU58. Based on the previous posts, it must have graded MS.
I like the second one better. Both are circulated, but I think the 1st one's been dipped.
Correct me if I'm wrong Jason, but you're not stating this coin deserves a bump up, you're saying that you will sell this coin when you find a 66...
I had a feeling that's why you started posting over here again.
I echo the comments about choosing the coin you want rather than letting them (seller)choose. I think the first thing to do is buy a reference...
This might not be practical, but it would be cool if they settled on say 3 obverses and 3 reverses, built the dies and let the collectors order...
Congrats on your set.
I'd agree with your assessments.
Add me to the 55 camp.
I grade it XF40. I didn't vote because I didn't believe in any of the choices.
Separate names with a comma.
