I consider you one of the more conservative graders on this forum, and even you had this graded higher than the TPG grade. My question for you...
It doesn’t need to go 66, MS65+ would be worth it. I’m stunned that this coin is in an MS64 holder. Unless @jtlee321 photos are so flattering...
Crack out & Resubmit!
[IMG]
So wait, you are saying that “barely toned” coins drive 2X premiums on a $500 price guide coin? That is patently absurd.
You need to have that coin graded by PCGS. That is MS66 FBL all day long with an excellent shot at MS67 FBL, luster dependent.
Nah, you bring it up cause your butt hurt about it. Which is all this argument is about. None of my scores are self contradictory and you know I...
Yes, I’m sending it to PCGS with my next submission.
Well, it’s basically worthless as an AT raw coin, I was thinking about using silver dip and hoping for the best. @ddddd thinks it might straight...
Oh please, says the guy who is still butt hurt over me me giving his coin a 1.0 score like 50 pages ago. You don't have the moral high ground, if...
I agree with all of this, hence why my score was 4.5 for the Buffalo.
Honestly, had you simply said the toning on the Buffalo lacks vibrancy, nobody would have questioned you, but when you try to claim the the coin...
In brg5658's world, this coin shown above is "highly toned" while the Buffalo shown below is "barely toned." And btw, my score of 1.0 was a...
You can offer your opinion, just make sure it is plausible. Your assertion that the Buffalo Nickel I posted is "barely toned" is ludicrous, and...
Actually, NO, the toned proof Jefferson Nickels from the 60's don't need a specific angle to see the toning. Many proof coins do need the angles...
Resorting to "I know you are but what am I" huh? I did rate that shilling as a 1.0 because I didn't think very much of the toning and most...
Again, stop whining, you are the only one who can't see the color in those photos.
I don't care about the spread or his low score, but saying that coin is "barely toned" is just factually inaccurate.
The 60's toned proof Jefferson's are striking. Heck, even V Kurt Bellman likes them, and he is a toning hating Wiemar White fan. I have owned...
In fairness, there really isn't that big of a spread in the scoring. wxcoin: 5.5 ddddd: 4.0 Morgandude11: 5.0 Lehigh96: 4.5 All of these...
Separate names with a comma.
