BTW, that "SUBTROPICAL DEPRESSION SEVENTEEN" is now called Otto.
There is nothing I can see that screams counterfeit to me, but there only one minor marker (offset VDB) that I can make out.
I will go with a 65
Sorry!
It was weirder than I thought it was, but I am pretty sure it is right now. Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses....
Yea, but it should have. I just checked it out and found Excel doesn't think the way I do. If you have 45 scores that are all off by 2 and just...
2 more to going until we reach 50. Still everyone is bunched together. Top 10. Columns are rank, name, average, and number of guesses. ldhair...
Solid strike, descent luster, nearly mark free - my guess is that the only thing keeping this from a higher grade is the spots. 64 sounds right...
Again, I could see this as a 64, but the color is not uniform and there are some spots - and they are all less obvious in hand. I am not sure...
Again the reverse is pretty solid, but the obverse is a bit busy. There is a die crack on Abe's forehead, several planchet marks, and I can count...
Solid reverse and the obverse is not too bad. Without the spots, a 67 would not surprise me. With them, 66 is right.
Yes, it affects the slab all the way around, but only where the 2 sides are in direct contact. Such things as dirt, grease, large gouges, warps,...
I suspect this coin is a 64 (65?), but, IMO, the blotchy coloring and spots kept it at a 63. Luster is not too bad, but not great either.
Some of you have seen this coin before. http://www.cointalk.com/t43153/. PCI called it 15, I thought it would come back 15, but PCGS called it...
I can believe that it is not a strong strike, but I cannot see 15. I am torn between a 10 and 12.
1958- NGC slabbed I will try to get the last 6 scored tomorrow. NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted
Sorry, but I put the wrong pictures up for Guess the grade #87 . Please vote again on the new #87.
1958-D PCGS slabbed I will try to get the last 6 scored tomorrow. NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted
I must say that I am very surprised. I have heard of several people ordering "replica" coins and that is the only one I have heard of being marked.
Separate names with a comma.
