Alright, I'm going to call this one. The guesses here seem pretty overwhelming. I'm actually not going to reveal the status of the 1813 until...
Really, it depends on whether or not the dealer wants your coins. Sometimes, they want you coins and a bit of extra cash gets you where you need...
AU-50, and a nice one.
Huh, a proof. Well, I totally missed that! Well played.
Nah, that's a little too far. I was going to go to the one in Charleston this weekend, but some things came up and I wasn't able to.
Well, that's not the sorta thing you normally buy! I'm going to say 64, based solely on the lack of luster I see. If, in hand, the luster is...
I don't know why people hide the grade in a photo like this.... but the barcode can easily by ready and has all the info you need.
Well, I nailed it. That's good.
Can you explain why you aren't "crazy" about this one?
The reveal will come tomorrow afternoon, after everyone gets a chance to guess.
Huh. Gotta say I'm actually really surprised by these guesses. I'm going to say absolutely yes this coin should have a star. And, @ddddd , if...
I haven't read the thread so I don't know what everyone else is saying, but are you entirely sure that coin is genuine? Because something looks...
Am I supposed to say whether it currently has a star or not? I feel like not posting it's current status gives a more unbiased opinion - and I'll...
Traditionally, its about 24 hours. That gives people enough time to respond, catches the night folks and the morning folks, and allows a good...
Simply gorgeous. This one is a solid 55.
Probably, yes. Many, many bust halves have had a bath over their lives. The difference, I think, is that its just a bit more obvious on this one....
I would have expected a little bit higher grade, based on what I'm seeing in the pictures. But, there are a lot of marks on the cheek, and that...
Because it has been dipped and retoned. The toning pattern on the obverse indicates secondary toning, and CAC usually does not sticker a coin like...
THAT'S A 53? Ain't no way. You've shown us quite a few halves over the past few days. A few of them were clearly overgraded. A couple of them...
If you do submit it, and you do get the PL.... let me know. If you don't want to submit it.... let me know.
Separate names with a comma.
