I think the op coin pretty but would be hard to get in a straight graded slab as the color doesn’t fit with most toned peace dollars. That being...
[ATTACH] [ATTACH]
Denticles seem weird cause those dies were worn out when struck. I think possibly cleaned but ok
Contemporary counterfeit maybe?
Slider and pretty but not sure it would straight grade
That is just atrocious
Monster from the deep. Just plain butt ugly
I prefer the old slabs too. Especially the early pcgs. To me a green or gold sticker on an old slab is always better than a new slab. Especially...
Very cool to be able to attribute the token it’s struck on
I disagree. I feel the coin has enough contact marks to be an au. Part of why my grade of 58. The rub plus the marks tell me it’s been handled...
Was at 64 before the reveal. Haven’t been on much lately as I been busy. My call a few marks but none too significant and luster making up for it
I wax torn between a crusty 63 and 58. I think that coin could easily go 62-3. Nice original and an absolutely crushed strike from fresh dies....
I saw some nicks and rub. I was torn between 55-58 and finally decided 58
I was at 66 no ft before the reveal just a tiny bit too much cheek chatter for higher great luster but not enough definition on the reverse for ft
Just wrong. The way some details are sharp and the rest crap on the 94 and the 08 with a type 1 reverse and mush for denticles both bad
A little late but I voted 65 before I saw the results. Too clean for less. Few too many marks for 66 and a great strike
I see a few marks of some significance especially on her leg and right obverse field 64
$395
Separate names with a comma.
