I think if you are talking CAC-language, it's just strong, average, and weak for the grade. And some of the A's might qualify for a 1 point...
Charley...FYI...I couldn't understand your post above...if you want to respond to multiple points separately you have to have the "quote" and...
GD, those Blue Circles areas...I can clearly see the discoloration (the blackish gold)...are you saying THAT is the wear ? It isn't just normal...
I might not be able to tell the difference. Thanks for circling those areas, but I honestly can't tell a major difference aside from the...
BTW....the OP here concerned that MS-69 1908 Wells Fargo Saint-Gaudens "The Best One"...it sold Sunday night for $286,875 (w/bp). I believe...
Maybe to an extent...but if I don't play by the rules everybody else is playing with, then I don't get to participate by buying (definitely) or...
Yeah, but try and buy an MS-66 Saint for MS-64 money because you insist and can prove that it is overgraded. I doubt the dealer agrees. :D
2004...he drilled it into me. :D
I'm just trying to learn about this whole debate. It's fascinating to me. I meant collecting in general, not you Charley. :D If theoretically...
Actually, GDJMSP has been very clear about why he doesn't like their grading standards. They use market grading, he is a purist who goes with...
But then how can you be 100% positive that the "wear" you see on high-points of a Saint or another coin are not multiple hits from coins banging...
But how do they DEFINE "wear" ? That's the rub. No pun intended. :D
So you're OK with no coins pre-1950 (certainly, not gold ones since gold is soft) being able to get an MS designation since it's going to be...
You did, and thanks. Did you have a number though ? MS-67 ? MS-66 ? I think from your details above that's where you would grade it.
The dollar does NOT trade in tandem with gold except for short spurts.
Well, what has happened to past "hot issues" from the Mint in the last 5-10 years ? The 2019 ASE Reverse Proof -- I think that was a $1,500 coin,...
Were the MSD's legit 69's or graded on a curve, in your opinion ? It's a big coin with big fields so blemishes show easily, unlike on a dime.
I would probably give it a 68 myself, though if you are going by comps, I can see why it got a 69. I see some tiny dings on the reverse rim, but...
I know we've had this debate before so I won't go into the "is it wear" thing again....but you do know that it is almost certainly the case that...
:D:D:D
Separate names with a comma.
