Congrats, that is a whole lot of posts! I have only one MAD, but it is a homemade, and it is a doozy! [IMG] [IMG] [IMG] PS: It's a Mad Mad Mad...
You and me both, coin #2 is far superior in eye appeal and deserves a star, a plus, something! C'mon NGC!
You are right about that, they just don't give stars for nickels anymore. As for the planchet roughness on cheek/jaw, they don't count that...
Are you sure you aren't an NGC grader? Your opinion of coins #2 & #3 seem to mirror what they must have been thinking.
IMO, this analysis is flawless, well done!
Ok guys, here is the story behind my 1948-D registry slot. In 2011 I purchased a 1948-D Jefferson Nickel ANACS MS66 5FS and cracked the coin out...
Many of the responses to this thread are incredible, and very similar to my analysis with one key difference which I will divulge along with the...
Does this mean you think #2 is lower graded than the other two?
@kSigSteve , @Lem E , @Morgandude11 , @Collecting Nut
Shown below are three NGC graded 1948-D Jefferson Nickels. Please vote in the attached poll indicating which coin your prefer and if you feel like...
+1
That is the reason I couldn't go MS67.
[IMG] [IMG] [IMG]
I forgot to post my 1913-D, mine is also T1. [img]
Holy cow Bob!
I think an ink pad and customizable stamper would be easier and look just as professional.
You have 50K posts in less than 7 years, that is like 20 posts per day, everyday. WOW!
Normally I would agree, but these photos are really small, I was basing my guess solely on luster and the cleanliness of the obverse focal areas....
MS66
1943/2-P Jefferson Nickel Raw [IMG] [IMG] [IMG] So my brother and I headed to New Castle Delaware last Friday to attend the 2022 Wilmington Coin...
Separate names with a comma.
