I personally stopped saving them, because, all things equal, the mintages are high in relation to the entire series and anything less then gem...
$30 BWR/CWR nickels - 41-S, 45-P, 46-D & 47-D
Nope...Denver only minted the copper-nickel alloy. Philadelphia minted in both alloys - copper-nickel and silver-manganese-etc, and San Fransisco...
$40 BWR nickels - 46-S, 57 & 59
Yeah...it's called 1964.
I keep the "lower" mintage ones (30-40 million mintage and less). I don't really know what to do with them either right now, but I only have...
$40 BWR/CWR nickels - 41-D, 49-S, 57 & 2x59
Got this G/AG 1913-D Type II for $7:
$40 CWR nickels - 40-D & 41-S
I have to re-roll. I haven't found any free coin counters in my area, so I generally do small quantities at a time (~$30 of nickels at a time)
I basically only search nickels and have only found one very corroded 1899 Liberty nickel. It was so bad that I actually released it back to the...
$72 BWR nickels - 41-S, 42, 42-D, 48-D & 49-S
A recent roll searching find:
So, if you come across a 50-D or 39-D, you won't keep it? I assume you would, but just wanted to make sure. If you don't, that's fine and more...
I keep the "lower" mintage pre-60 ones. Generally, anything 30-40 million mintage or less. Nickels starting me coin collecting as a pre-teen and...
And yours is more dramatic than that one. I hope you do well on it (provided you decide to sell it).
$30 CWR nickels - 38-S, 41-D, 43-P & 53-S
Also big hitters: 1901-S Quarter 1913-S Quarter
Here's the 50-D from yesterday:
That too. Fun with percentage! :p
Separate names with a comma.