I’m not a 100% sure on this one (nor was PCGS :p), but it does not look obviously AT. I’ll steer towards MA
According to Doug, USNAF is on “vacation” so it might be a while before we hear the answer to this one.
Well @Mainebill broke the tie on the last Kennedy. That was our closest NT winner yet (we had an AT winner decided by one vote too-Coin #8). I'm...
Summary of results: ----------------------- Coin 1 - Clad Dime (pg.1) - 2 (NT/MA) vs 6 (AT/QC) Coin 2 - Franklin (pg. 1) - 3 (NT/MA) vs 7 (AT/QC)...
Thread revival...those that guessed MS 63 are also correct! :D [ATTACH]
Since it was bought raw but as an MS, I'll go: Bought: $150 Sold: $250
Anyone else? It seems like we went over 24 hours with Mainebill's vote, so let's give this until the top of the hour until I call it officially.
@Mainebill do you have a price guide for that coin? I'm not sure what a regular 58 would go for.
That might be true, but never say never. :p In a system where the best coins are ranked (or "market grading"), there may come a time when MS 67+...
MS 66 ...I don’t think the color would earn a star but maybe it’s just not popping in the image
That was pretty much my point. I think it might be MA, but it’s funny that no one realized they had it as an example of AT (especially after...
@capthank we have moved on to the 1890 Morgan that is on this page. Please share your thoughts on that coin. :)
You can post it but I won’t since I promised no TruViews in that thread.
Apparently PCGS thought this was awkward too as they removed a similar thread with this Peace Dollar that was posted on their forum. :p
[IMG] [IMG] [IMG] [IMG]
To be fair, it did grade MS 64 at least four times. So if we take the median or mode grade, then MS 64 fits. :p...
for PCGS and this Peace Dollar.... ~Example for questionable color:[ATTACH] MS 64: [ATTACH]
Next up is this Kennedy (not mine): [IMG] [IMG]
How about this Morgan? [IMG] [IMG]
Separate names with a comma.
