The doily holder is fairly scarce and collected enthusiasticly by some. The eBay price on this example is too high in my opinion. I would say a...
MS 64 I agree with others that mention the scratches on the cheek preventing a 65.
MS 63
AU 58
Summary update will happen after we finish with the coin above. I’ll say the Quarter has a large distracting spot to the left of Washington’s...
I wouldn't let the voting steer your decision. You made some solid observations. The coin is most likely market graded, that is why it's in a 68+...
Hello all! There are four "lots" available here. Please message me with any questions. Shipping is free for all lots! Payment via paypal (I'll...
Why do you think you blew it?
+2 ...although I'll expand it to anywhere in the 63 to 67 range. I'm going with 66 based on luster and clean fields.
I’ll go MS 65
It depends how you define restoration. A coin that is dipped can be “restored” to remove surface contaminants and then still be gradeable. It has...
I see a few of those orbs on the obverse (like to the left of the Y in Liberty), but I don’t believe this one had anything applied to it. I’ll go...
I agree with your point that the Morgans should mostly be treated equally, but unfortunately that doesn’t seem to be the case. By the way, what...
@Lehigh96 go ahead and post the next one.
Summary of results: ----------------------- Coin 1 - Clad Dime (pg.1) - 2 (NT/MA) vs 6 (AT/QC) Coin 2 - Franklin (pg. 1) - 3 (NT/MA) vs 7 (AT/QC)...
You may have listed it too low! But in this case I’d think it’s better to have a quick profitable sale with a happy customer than sitting on it...
I think it’s ok once in a while. Maybe one can also mention that the coin should not be VAMed or attributed. Just focus on grade.
That was directed towards a poster asking about modern mint products. I even quoted their question: [ATTACH] I answered the original question on...
@jtlee321 I still think it’s a 65. And I like your method (maybe it’s because I don’t try to VAM :D); it helped remove the bias of the more...
Theoretically you could have the argument of bumping down the 60 and bumping up the 58, but in practice all we would see is people having to spend...
Separate names with a comma.
