Well then I'll double down on my original 62 vote. :p
@ToughCOINS did anything change with this one? I didn't vote as I remember the answer.
I voted VF 35 ....I believe at least a trace of luster is needed for XF (but maybe that's just me reading Insider's posts from how grading used to...
I went with MS 63 (looks like nice luster but some marks, like that reverse hit)...I also think these are hard to grade, so it'll be interesting...
Points table: ddddd - 39.26 Points Beefer518 - 31.26 Points baseball21 - 26.61 Points heavycam.monstervam - 23.51 Points Duke Kavanaugh - 23.51...
Yes I have a similar mindset as what @Murphy45p described. Here is a link to my thread where a good deal of coins came from details holders (or...
25
If it has sentimental value, just put it in a flip (maybe mark it as 'Dad's Dollar) and leave it as is. If you don't mind experimenting with it,...
They are all nice, but I would not count on any receiving a star. I have seen some like this with a star and others without one. Even with the...
@Paddy54 you're next... Points table: ddddd - 39.26 Points Beefer518 - 31.26 Points baseball21 - 26.61 Points heavycam.monstervam - 23.51 Points...
$100
66 ...looks clean throughout but average eye appeal (at least from my interpretation of the photos) prevents a higher grade
Small White Anacs holder? I voted 65 PL....photos appear to show the PL qualities....a few marks at the bottom of the cheek, below the S of...
64
Floor is open...
I'm not surprised to see it up for sale so soon and at a significant mark up. Now it'll be interesting to see if it sells....
@kanga your thought process is correct (in my opinion). If $5,000 is the market value of the coin, then bidding $5,000 would be too high (it would...
The gold sticker could push the old holder 65 beyond the 67. It's no certainty (I've seen some sell for below 67 prices while others were more)....
I don't think they are 2 grade apart either. I believe the coin in the first post is the nicest of the three, but at most by 1 point. The two 67s...
Separate names with a comma.
