62...UNC but weak strike and some hits
That’s a nice looking 65
I voted 30 (potential net grading for the hole)
I agree with the others that it looks like a problem coin, either cleaned or altered surfaces and then retoned (possibly on its own, but at that...
Which two? The ones with CAC stickers? The first (w/ CAC) and the third (no CAC). Both appear to have some significant (at least for a 65)...
At least two of those Barbers look a point too high even without the unattractive eye appeal. The last one is in an older holder, so there is a...
It’s easier to say one would take the risk after the item sold. ;) It could just as easily have sat around for a year and no one showed interest....
Sounds like he did well. It doesn’t appear to have sold on eBay, so the person must have found a buyer on another platform. The $4,500 is still...
I voted details due to the scratch/damage on the reverse through the rim and E in Quarter Otherwise I think it would have received a nice UNC grade.
XF 40
If you need to take a picture in the future where the website does not allow downloading, screenshots and a snipping tool are two good options....
I split the difference between 63 and 64 by voting 63+ :p
I guessed 62 and was way off. Grading gold is quite the challenge.
The last one was the only one that looked undergraded at 65+ ....at 68 it's certainly maxed out. Four of the five only received a green sticker...
I missed seeing this one in time. It looked a point better than the previous Morgan (based on being less baggy). I graded that one 62, so my grade...
The 68 would almost certainly be two grades lower. The others would be lower too. The first example (65+ to 67) has a few reeding marks on the...
Most looked to be correct, and had the green CAC as evidence (besides the 65+ which CACed at 65+ and 67+). Some might have even started in lower...
Here is a recent example of a big color bump: https://www.cointalk.com/threads/guess-the-grade-morgan-toner.344695/ This thread also has some...
And for the 3c, I’m guessing the Anacs holder caused it to go low... -$250 -MS 63 at PCGS
My mistake... @Mainebill you were closest in the last round Edited: Points table: ddddd - 39.26 Points Beefer518 - 31.26 Points baseball21 -...
Separate names with a comma.
