Fair enough. It is interesting that his opinion isn't followed in the grading room. In fact, we continue to see some really questionable stars...
I agree with the idea that the color has to grab you in order to earn a star. However, the obverse only part I believe is flawed. Why should only...
@Coinsandmedals world coins are perfectly fine on this thread (some has been posted before). The pl/cameo stars are harder to judge, but we can...
Reminder of the basic rules: 1. Post an NGC toned coin with a star designation or without a star. 2. Everyone will have around 24 hours to give an...
I'm reviving this thread with a pair of coins. Should either one have received a star? (1) [IMG] [IMG] (2) [IMG] [IMG]
Next up is another Morgan. Generic MS 65s have been selling for $100 (give or take $15). What did this one sell for at auction last week? [IMG] [IMG]
Points table: ddddd - 44.26 Points Beefer518 - 31.26 Points Duke Kavanaugh - 30.51 Points baseball21 - 26.61 Points Lehigh96 - 25.51 Points...
eBay will certainly not be a fan of that. And it's technically against the rules, but it does happen all the time. eBay's fees and policies have...
I’ll update standings and post something later tonight. The colors are strong and I was guessing the premium would be high. I often find it...
In general, I would say that various Art Coins can be great to collect. I would suggest to do some research on the ones that interest you and see...
The “Art Coins” made by foreign mints (like the Mint of Poland, Perth Mint, CIT, etc) can have a strong collector base (usually not so much on...
This is relatively new on eBay (has been around for a year or so). When a seller has watchers for an item, eBay allows the seller to send an offer...
I’m guessing VF Details on the holder; either corrosion or environmental damage
Nothing new from eBay. @TheFinn was right that they will say things just to make you get off the phone. There is still a chance I’m wrong and...
$285
Yes the population/census reports should give you the info. One can also get to the same place by entering the cert number of any coin (you might...
Saying they are very generous is not accurate. The two TPGs are fairly close in the way they grade (in fact NGC is more strict on some...
Just a small correction. NGC changed their policy a few years back where they now only allow PCGS for crossover (others are treated as raw). PCGS...
@riff any word from eBay about your refund?
That is what I expect, but for now I'm hoping they prove me wrong. In Illinois, there isn't even much hope for a refund from the state. I've only...
Separate names with a comma.
