I think yours is a fair 3 since it has a nice spectrum of color even for a crescent. The examples I linked are fairly plain and in my view aren't...
And some more while I was looking (including non-Morgans)...
One more that might barely be a 2 https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/859656/1896-Morgan-Silver-Dollar-NGC-MS-63-226-152-133-Toned (and this...
I’d call all of these 2s (maybe some can be bumped into low 3s, but not in my view)...
It’s a beautiful coin and you made the right call in hanging onto it!
I agree in theory that nothing with a star should rank in the theees but in practice NGC has even given two level toners stars.
Anyone else want to rate the Franklin posted by @Lehigh96 before he gives his score?
Any particular reason for it? Good for quizzes? :p
I believe the last ones used were in the 1999 Mint set. Starting in 2000 they were no longer included. Some links below...1998 has it, 1999 does...
@gxseries in one of the old threads about these you mentioned trying to hoard a few of the 2006. Did you ever do so or collect the series?
Lots of great examples so far! @Beefer518 how about the opposite with the least number of characters? :p [ATTACH]
I'm neutral on it. The spotted toning around the rim detracts a bit for me. The grade seems fair. I've recently seen a few lower graded ones that...
Some other random thoughts: ~When I first saw these coins the prices on eBay for all were ~$90 or more (2013-2014). At that time it seemed too...
Toned ASEs can be attractive (even some of the AT ones) and command large premiums. Those examples don't look very appealing to me and are...
I'm equally bad as you all :p MS 63
Bonus coin - BAIKONUR Date of release: 07.27.2012 Quality: Proof Mintage: 5,000 Notes: This coin is part of a different series - The Heritage of...
Coin #10 in the series - VENERA-10 Date of release: 12.25.2015 Quality: Proof Mintage: 3,000 Notes: This is the third year where the color of the...
Coin #9 in the series - BURAN Date of release: 01.28.2015 Quality: Proof Mintage: 3,000 Notes: This is the second year where the color of the...
Coin #8 in the series - ISS (INTERNATIONAL SPACE STATION) Date of release: 10.18.2013 Quality: Proof Mintage: 5,000 Notes: This is the first year...
Coin #7 in the series - MIR SPACE STATION Date of release: 04.28.2012 Quality: Proof Mintage: 5,000 Notes: This year returned back to the style...
Separate names with a comma.
